*Prior to posting, an update already occurred and is posted at the bottom. In my view it was too little too late and has not changed my mind, so this post, while a bit late, is still valid.
God help me, I’m moving my blogs again.
This time it isn’t my fault, or me running after something shinny and new; I don’t want to move, but I feel I must. It’s a matter of principle, which is another way of saying I know it’s a daft thing to do but I’m doing it anyway.
WordPress and I never really saw eye-to-eye. We had a brief flirtation back in the spring of 2009 but WordPress turned out to be what you might call a high-maintenance partner and I soon tired of it.
I went back to WordPress last year for one specific reason: I did not like the look of my Blogger blogs.
This was a problem I wrestled with for months but always came away from my time-consuming tinkering with the idea that the blogs still didn’t look quite…right. And as I surfed the Blogsphere, I began to notice that every blog I liked the look of was a WordPress blog. And then I read a book about self-publishing that said if you wanted to be a serious self-publisher you needed to get a WordPress blog because they looked more professional. And I could not argue with that.
So I switched.
The first thing I found was that I couldn’t tinker behind the scenes the way I did in Blogger. Then I discovered I could modify the CSS files and spent an afternoon learning CSS and once I got the blog looking right in the previews, I clicked SAVE. Then, and only then, did a pop-up tell me I had to pay $30 a year for the privilege. That sort of practice rankled me, but I pressed on. A few months later, I finally figured out how to link a video to my blog posts. A few weeks after that I attempted to link another one and a pop-up told me I had to pay $59.97 per year for the privilege. I convinced myself that linking videos was a stupid idea and pressed on.
Then, this weekend I logged in to find my blog had changed. I like my Postcards blog to have a single post showing on the front page, like an article, because the posts are articles. I think it looks and read better and allows visitors to see the footer widgets. But now ALL my posts appeared in a long line as if I had rolled them all out on toilet paper. I spend hours checking my configurations and testing different settings. When I ran out of options, I checked WordPress help, which was no help at all, and then I Googled it (Note to self: always, always, always go to Google first.)
Apparently, WordPress had decided, without telling us, to “enhance” our blogs with this new “feature” – a feature that does NOT contain an opt-out setting – and what did we think of it.
Well, hundreds told them what they thought, and all but one hated it. At the very least, they argued, an opt-out option was necessary. WordPress responded by ignoring their customers for two days then shutting down the complaint threads. Their only statement on the subject, so far, has been a cheery, “Thanks for the feedback; we don’t care what you think so we’re going to roll this out to the rest of our customers, as well.” (They initially did this on the Twenty-Ten and Twenty-Eleven themes—the theme I recently switched to, naturally.)
I was, and remain, gobsmacked.
The idea of moving back to Blogger seemed impossible at first, but I have not been gone that long so, in actuality, moving all my posts, notifying all my followers, swapping over the URLS and—this is the key component—making my Blogger blogs look like my WordPress blogs, shouldn’t be that huge a job. So I’m going to do it.
In addition to no longer having to deal with a company that decides for me, and without notifying me, what my blog should look like and then forces their decision on me, I also receive the following perks:
Feature Free Blogger blog Free WordPress blog
Code access $0 $30
Link Videos $0 $59.97
No Ads $0 $29.97
Redirect $0 $12
URL Hosting $10 $17
Additionally, if you want to access features on your chosen theme beyond the basic options, you often need to pay for an upgrade, which can run anywhere from $25 into the hundreds.
To get what I get in Blogger for $10 a year I have to pay at least $150 a year to WordPress. For each blog. And I have four blogs.
So hang on, we’re going for a ride; if I do this right, you shouldn’t feel too many bumps.
And, unlike WordPress, I’ll keep you updated.
=========================================
For those interested in what WordPress actually said, here is the complete test of both letters, their only word on this to date:
http://en.forums.wordpress.com/topic/to-infinity?replies=136
8 Feb 2012 [I have added my own comments because this is my blog and I can]:
In the quest to make visitors engage with your content as effortlessly as possible we are rolling out a new feature to your blog home pages—infinite scrolling! Instead of having to scroll and click through older-pages links we are now pulling new content automatically whenever a visitor approaches the bottom of a blog.
Best thing, it should be entirely transparent to you or your readers. The feature is enabled for blogs with the Twenty Ten or Twenty Eleven themes.
We take care of the smaller details, such as removing the older/next links, integrating with your design as smoothly as possible. Having said that, please let us know what you think by posting any feedback you may have. Thanks.
[Cue several hundred angry WordPress users telling them how they have just destroyed hours worth of work and begging for, if not a reversal, at least a way to opt-out.]
10 Feb 2012 [two days later]
Howdy guys, thanks for the feedback.
The initial usage stats from infinite scroll look really good — people are reading more posts which means they’re spending more time on your site. [Actually, this was the thousands of incredulous blog owners who, like me, kept scrolling through their blogs trying to figure out want was wrong.] As you might guess, people are way more likely to just scroll down than they were to click the “next page” button — it’s faster and better. [Who says it’s better?] It’s the future of all web pages with more than one page of content. [Again, who decided this?]
We’re still working out some bugs, and as some of you noted your footer widgets are temporarily inaccessible, and figuring out the best way to deal with that and other edge cases.
A few people have asked if “everyone” is against this why we’re just not turning it off. Well, there’s a thread like this which seems overly negative for pretty much everything we launch. People don’t come to the forums to say they like something they usually come when they have a problem. [So, basically, you’re not believing what your users are telling you.] That’s why we ask for feedback on the forums, to find the problems, not to gauge popularity. For that we’ve learned to look at stats, what people do versus what they say. [If you don’t offer them a choice they have to do as you say even if they hate it.] This is better [Again, who decided this is better?] because it allows us to get feedback from millions of people in addition to the few thousand who frequent the forums. Both voices are important.
Thanks for your patience, and as we fix these issues up we’ll continue rolling out infinite scrolling [the plan was to roll it out to everyone all along, regardless of user feedback] to the rest of the themes that work with it. Also thank you to the people on the thread who provided calm, rational feedback without attacks or hyperbole. The team is always here for you.
13 Feb 2012 [I checked yesterday as I was writing this post and this update was not there at that time]
An update on infinite scroll: Thanks for your feedback and patience, everybody. If you’re using footer widgets to display content in your blog, you can now disable infinite scrolling by visiting your Reading settings, in your dashboard. We’re still working on improving the reading experience with infinite scroll, including how well it integrates with your themes and customizations.
Like this:
One blogger likes this post.